Various Novels – Hal Clement

Posted: July 02, 1993
Originally posted on Usenet

Belated Reviews #6: Hal Clement

Hal Clement dominates a specific hard-sf niche. He designs worlds. Now, you might have doubts about a book-long planetology lecture, thinly disguised as a novel. Clement made it work, for his audience, better than Forward, who followed in his footsteps, ever made it work for his own. Clement’s written a number of entertaining books, but three in particular, from the fifties and sixties, stand out:

Mission of Gravity (***). The planet Mesklin is unique: Its enormous size and rapid rotation have combined to produce a planet whose surface gravity is three times that of Earth at the equator – and increases to seven-hundred times that of Earth at the poles. When an exceedingly expensive unmanned probe fails, the team researching the planet contacts a native trader (at the equator, naturally), and persuades him to retrieve the probe. For his own reasons, he agrees. What would conditions be like on a world where all falls are fatal falls and missile weapons are a good way to get holes in your feet? In a way, Mission of Gravity is a novel- length science lecture superimposed upon a storyline, but it works. If you read one book by Clement, read this one.

Close to Critical (***). Once again there’s a story of humans interacting with the natives of an unusual planet, but once again the real star of the book is the planet itself. In this case it’s the planet Tenebra, a high- gravity planet with a surface temperature of close to four hundred degrees (fahrenheit, presumably), a pressure of eight hundred atmospheres, and a somewhat corrosive atmosphere. (This is a planet where talking about the weather is not idle chit-chat.) The leisurely study of this planet, however, becomes rushed when two children are accidentally stranded on it.

Cycle of Fire (***) follows the usual pattern, only this time the planet on which the obligatory crash takes place is not, in itself, unusual. Except that its orbit, which is unusual, is about to enter the phase in which the entire biosphere burns to a crisp. Which calls for some unusual adaptations, especially for an intelligent species.


Dani Zweig dani@netcom.com

The inability of snakes to count is actually a refusal, on their part, to appreciate the Cardinal Number system. – “Actual Facts”


View Reader Response from Usenet (1993)
From: reader@netcom.com Subject: Re: Belated Reviews #1: A.E. Van Vogt From /tmp/sf.4258 Tue Feb 1 03:00:54 1994 Newsgroups: rec.arts.sf.written Path: lysator.liu.se!isy!liuida!sunic!uunet!noc.near.net!howland.reston.ans.net!agate!headwall.Stanford.EDU!nntp.Stanford.EDU!nntp!doom From: doom@elaine36.Stanford.EDU (Joseph Brenner) Subject: Re: Belated Reviews #6: Hal Clement In-Reply-To: dani@netcom.com's message of Fri, 2 Jul 1993 16:47:48 GMT Message-ID: <DOOM.93Jul4224613@elaine36.Stanford.EDU> Sender: news@leland.Stanford.EDU (Mr News) Organization: DSO, Stanford University References: <daniC9Jqno.KvE@netcom.com> Date: 4 Jul 93 22:46:13 Lines: 35 Not a bad belated review of Clement, certainly I'd rate "Mission of Gravity" as the first one to read... but there was no mention of one of my fave Clement books. I believe the correct title is _Needle_ (as in "Needle in a haystack"), though the edition I first read is was an old paperback re-titled something like _It Came From Outer Space_. The story takes place in a small island community where an alien criminal has gone to ground, with an alien cop not far behind him. These aliens however have evolved from viruses, and normally exist in close symbiosis with other species... they "ride" inside them, performing some services (e.g. killing parasites) in return for the use of their sense organs and mobility. The cop lands, and oozes inside of a young boy he finds on the beach, and then has to (a) establish communications with the boy (b) find a criminal who could be hiding inside of any random person. One of the impressive things about this book is that Clement makes no cop-outs like assuming some sort of "telepathy". The cop has to take time to learn english, and has to work out some more down to earth means of communication. And the eventual detection of the criminal is also entirely logical given the premises of the story, requiring no deus ex machinas like building a "parasite detector" or something. Another impressive thing is that this is an excellent "boys" adventure novel. The kids in the story practically live on the beach, messing around with decaying abandoned row boats, snorkling, etc. When I was around ten or so I *really* wanted to be in their shoes (or lack thereof...).